Home › Guides › Your home insurance went up at renewal. Here’s what to do.

Your home insurance went up at renewal. Here’s what to do.

A big renewal increase is stressful, but you usually have about a month before the new price starts. Use that time to ask questions and compare.

6-minute read · Updated · Free, no sign-up needed

The short version

  1. Ask your insurer or agent exactly why the price went up.
  2. Check your dwelling coverage amount and every discount.
  3. Consider a higher deductible only if you can afford it.
  4. Compare quotes with the same coverage, then decide.

Know your timeline

The CFPB says your insurer tells you the cost for the next year about a month before your renewal date, and should tell you one to three months before the renewal date if it decides not to renew. (CFPB: Take action when home insurance is cancelled or costs surge)

1. Ask why it went up

Call your agent or insurer and ask for the reasons. The NAIC lists common factors: where you live, your claims history, the cost to replace your home (which is different from its market value), your insurance score, your deductible, your home’s age and roof, and fire protection. Wider costs such as extreme weather, construction costs, inflation and reinsurance also play a part. (NAIC: Why are my insurance premiums increasing?)

You: “My renewal went from $[old] to $[new]. Can you tell me what changed? Did my coverage amount, discounts or rating change?”

2. Check your coverage amount

Maryland’s insurance regulator suggests asking your insurer to recalculate the value of your home: if your dwelling coverage is too high, your premium will be too high. Don’t cut it below what it would cost to rebuild. (Maryland Insurance Administration: Homeowners insurance rate increases)

3. Check every discount

Ask about discounts for smoke detectors, burglar alarms, monitored security systems, deadbolt locks and sprinkler systems, and about bundling home and auto. (NAIC: Why are my insurance premiums increasing?) Some insurers also give discounts for upgrades such as a new roof. (Maryland Insurance Administration: Homeowners insurance rate increases) Ask your state insurance department whether it has a grant program for strengthening your roof or home. (NAIC: Why are my insurance premiums increasing?) See bundle vs separate policies.

4. Think about your deductible

A higher deductible lowers your premium, but only choose one you could pay out of pocket if you had a claim. Also ask whether your deductible is a fixed dollar amount or a percentage of your home’s insured value, and whether your policy pays replacement cost or actual cash value. (NAIC: Why are my insurance premiums increasing?)

5. Compare like-for-like quotes

Get quotes from other companies using your current policy as a guide, so you compare the same coverages. (Maryland Insurance Administration: Homeowners insurance rate increases) Your state insurance department can tell you which companies operate in your area. (CFPB: Take action when home insurance is cancelled or costs surge) Before you cancel anything, make sure the new policy is in place, and if you have a mortgage, that it meets your lender’s requirements. A lapse can lead your lender to buy expensive “force-placed” insurance for you. (CFPB: Take action when home insurance is cancelled or costs surge)

6. If something looks wrong

If you think the increase is improper, ask your insurer to review it, and you can file a complaint with your state insurance department. (Maryland Insurance Administration: Homeowners insurance rate increases)

Common questions

Why did my home insurance go up if I didn’t file a claim?

Premiums depend on more than your own claims. The NAIC lists factors such as where you live, the cost to rebuild your home, extreme weather, construction costs, inflation and the insurer’s own reinsurance costs.

How can I lower my homeowners insurance after an increase?

Ask why it went up, check your dwelling coverage amount, ask about every discount and bundling, consider a higher deductible you can afford, and compare quotes with the same coverage.

Should I cancel my home insurance and switch?

Only after the new policy is in place. If you have a mortgage, make sure the new policy meets your lender’s requirements, because a lapse can lead to costly force-placed insurance.

Keep going

Sources

Wisebuddy guides are general information, not financial, legal or insurance advice. Prices, plans and rules change, so check current terms with your provider.

Want someone to do this for you?

Wisebuddy is building an AI helper that finds savings on your phone, internet, insurance and subscription bills, and asks before it changes anything. You pay 25% of verified first-year savings, and nothing if we save you nothing. Join the waitlist for early access.

We’ll only email you about Wisebuddy. Privacy policy